1119 S Main St in New Castle
Back to listings
Roots listing · SOLD
New Castle · IN

1119 S Main St

New Castle · IN

4Bedrooms
3Bathrooms
2,364Square feet
Roots take

What to know about this one.

Discover the epitome of timeless elegance in this beautifully updated four bedroom masterpiece, perfectly situated on a prime corner lot in downtown New Castle. Step inside to original hardwood floors glowing under huge picture windows that flood the open-concept main level with natural light. A cozy fireplace anchors the living room, flowing into a charming breakfast nook and formal dining room. The remodeled kitchen shines with a built-in Sub-Zero fridge, electric induction cooktop, built-in oven, and hidden dishwasher tucked into the solid wood cabinetry. The primary suite is a serene retreat with a custom cedar-lined closet and plenty of natural light. Upstairs, you'll find three more versatile bedrooms with matching cedar-lined storage and another full bathroom. The fully finished basement, with new carpeting, a second fireplace, and a half bathroom, offers space for entertaining or maybe even a home gym! Outside, an elevated patio with a built-in gas grill overlooks a tranquil koi pond and brick fenced in yard, perfect for gatherings with friends and family. A one-car attached garage and low-maintenance exterior with fresh landscaping give this house practicality and show stopping curb appeal. Steps from shops, parks, and New Castle Community Schools, with I-70 nearby for easy commutes to Indianapolis or Muncie, this home blends small-town charm with convenience. This home is priced to sell! Schedule a tour today before it's gone.

Features
Garage
Laundry
Dishwasher
Stainless appliances
Fenced yard
Garden
Where it is

1119 S Main St

New Castle, IN 47362

Open in Google Maps
Listed by
Listed
Apr 30, 2026
Status
Sold
Address
1119 S Main St, New Castle, IN 47362
Keep looking

More Roots listings.

All listings
3034 Guilford Avenue in Indianapolis
ActiveHouse hack
9
House hack
$199,900

3034 Guilford Avenue

Indianapolis

Check out this stunning, fully updated 4-bed, 2-bath craftsman style bungalow in Monon Yard, just minutes to near north side staples like the Monon Trail, Goose the Market and Command Coffee. CURRENTLY RENTED FOR $1,845/month THROUGH AUGUST 2026! This is not your typical investment property - updated top to bottom with modern finishes while keeping its original craftsman charm. With approximately 1,800 finished square feet across two levels, you'll find LVP flooring through the main living areas, white shaker cabinets with butcher block countertops, marble-look tile in both bathrooms with matte black fixtures, black trim on every window and door, new carpet in all bedrooms, and appliances included. The open main-floor layout features original columns, a decorative fireplace, and a covered front porch with painted white brick and iron railings giving this home incredible curb appeal. Upstairs bedrooms offer cozy sloped ceilings with built-in closets. Additional features include a basement with newer HVAC and water heater and a large detached garage. Currently tenant-occupied with a lease through August 2026 at $1,845/month - a turnkey investment with immediate cash flow. Check it out before it's gone!

4 bd / 2 ba / 2918 sqftView
1119 S Randolph St in Indianapolis
Active
9
Investor pick
$249,900

1119 S Randolph St

Indianapolis

Companion property to 1123, furnished mid-term rental sold as a pair.

2 bd / 2 ba / 998 sqftView
806 Cameron St in Indianapolis
Active
9
Starter home
$209,900

806 Cameron St

Indianapolis

Welcome to 806 Cameron Street-where 1920s charm meets modern flair in the heart of Garfield Park! This storybook bungalow is the kind of home that makes you smile before you even step inside. From its irresistible curb appeal to the warm, character-filled interior, every corner feels like it was designed to be loved. Inside, you'll find original hardwoods and timeless parquet flooring that carry the home's historic soul, perfectly complemented by fresh paint throughout. The updated kitchen (2023) is truly a showstopper-featuring Corian countertops, sleek recessed lighting, dramatic black tile backsplash, and eye-catching ceiling wallpaper that adds just the right amount of personality. The dining room is straight out of a magazine, complete with a window seat with hidden storage and built-in shelving-ideal for slow mornings, coffee in hand, or hosting intimate dinners. Both bedrooms offer comfort and charm, while the fully remodeled bathroom (2023) shines with a new vanity, countertop, backsplash, sink, toilet, light fixture, and mirror-bringing a fresh, modern touch to this classic home. Step outside and you'll discover a fully fenced, private backyard-perfect for entertaining, pets, or simply unwinding under the stars. The detached garage and shed have also been refreshed with new trim and paint (2025), adding even more polish to the property. Major updates provide peace of mind: Roof (2018), HVAC (2019), Electrical fully upgraded, including panel (2022), Water heater (2023). And the location? Hard to beat. You're just minutes from Garfield Park, with quick access to I-65 & I-465, and a short drive to the energy of Fountain Square and Downtown Indy! Whimsical, welcoming, and wonderfully updated-this is the kind of home that doesn't come around often. Come see why 806 Cameron Street feels like "The One!"

2 bd / 1 ba / 1 034 sqftView
Talk to Roots

Curious about a similar one?

Book a consultation and a Roots agent will help you watch for the next fit.

Sold for$238,000
Find one like it