Skip to content

5144 N College Avenue

Indianapolis, IN 46205

ActiveListed May 1, 2026 · 86 days on market

Key facts

Beds
4
Baths
2 full · 1 half
Living area
4,134 sqft
Lot
0.16 acres
Year built
1928
Type
Residential · Single Family Residence
Stories
Two
Garage
2 spaces
MLS #
22099303
County
Marion
Subdivision
Hartmans College Ave
Total building area
4,289 sqft

About this home

REDUCE BY $10,000! This home is a perfect blend of classic features & quality updates starting with the ALL-BRICK exterior & large covered front porch with its tiled floor & bead board ceiling. The large 2-car garage & privacy fence make for a cozy yard & patio experience. Step inside & the main level dazzles with original SOLID hardwoods under foot. Smooth ceilings & crown molding = good vibes. The living room, anchored by a masonry fireplace & tiled hearth, flows seamlessly through the arched passage into the HUGE dining room. And it all connects to the gorgeous kitchen with exposed brick complementing the modern amenities like the perfectly sized center island, true exterior exhaust fan, open shelving & charming shiplap. Loads of cabinetry & countertop space. The primary & 2nd bedrooms are on the main level & both have good closets, ceiling fans & natural light. The well-equipped full bathroom for these 2 bedrooms features a raised double vanity, tub & shower combo with tiled walls, rainforest shower, built-in shelving, tiled floor, and tasteful lights between the 2 arched mirrors. The main level also includes a versatile office & mudroom-style area off the kitchen with a bench & hooks. Ascend the gradual, wood staircase to discover the cheery upper level with its expansive loft including a built-in daybed nook, more cool shiplap walls, attractive metal railing, lots of recessed lighting...AND its own HVAC system! Bedrooms 3 & 4 on this level share a terrific full bath with a raised vanity & walk-in tiled shower. The carpet is fresh! The finished basement is still bone dry even after the historic rains! It includes a 1/2 bath & large laundry room plus a nice rec/bonus room with daylight windows. Good storage with multiple closets & 2 unfinished rooms. This home enjoys TOPS convenience with the library, Monon Trail, art galleries, eateries & shops all close. Skip driving - easy access to the Red Line. Great Home!

Description provided by the listing brokerage.

Interior

Appliances
DishwasherDryerDisposalGas Water HeaterExhaust FanMicrowaveElectric OvenRange HoodRefrigeratorWasherWater HeaterWine Cooler
Interior features
Attic AccessBath Sinks Double MainBreakfast BarBuilt-in FeaturesKitchen IslandPaddle FanHi-Speed Internet AvailblEat-in KitchenWired for DataSmart ThermostatSupplemental StorageWood Work Stained
Kitchen
Kitchen Updated
Other rooms and areas
Bedroom Other on Main
Flooring
Hardwood
Basement
DaylightPartially FinishedStorage Space
Fireplaces
1
Fireplace type
Family Room
Laundry
Connections AllLaundry RoomIn Basement
Windows
ScreensStorm Window(s)Wood Frames
Rooms
11
Main-level bedrooms
2
Condition
Updated/Remodeled

Exterior

Exterior features
Lighting
Patio and porch
CoveredPatio
Construction
Brick
Foundation
Block
Style
BungalowTraditional
Parking and garage
Detached
Fencing
FullPrivacy
Other equipment
Security System OwnedSmoke Alarm

Systems

Heating
Forced AirNatural Gas
Cooling
Central Air
Water
Public
Utilities
Cable AvailableElectricity ConnectedNatural Gas AvailableNatural Gas ConnectedSewer ConnectedWater Connected

Lot and HOA

Lot features
BuslineSidewalksStorm SewerStreet LightsMature TreesTrees-Small (Under 20 Ft)

Schools

Middle school
James Whitcomb Riley School 43
High school
Shortridge High School
School district
Indianapolis Public Schools

Taxes

Estimated annual tax
$8,204 / yearTwice the semi-annual installment the listing reports.
Tax year
2025

Estimate your monthly payment

$4,025per month, estimated
Principal and interest $3,125Property tax $684Insurance $217
20% · $123,980
6.47%
Loan type
Loan term

Estimates only. This calculator does not give a quote. Defaults reflect Marion County / Indianapolis averages: property tax from this home's actual county bill, homeowners insurance at 0.42% annually. Conventional: PMI runs 0.55% of the loan annually when your down payment is below 20%, and drops automatically at 22% equity. Your real number depends on credit, taxes assessed for the parcel, escrow, condo insurance, and HOA. Rates as of May 2026 and subject to change.

Talk to a lender we trust
Talk to Roots

Want us to run the numbers with you?

Book a consultation and a Roots agent will help you pressure-test the payment, repairs, resale, and rent.

Listed at$619,900
Talk to Roots

Ready to plant roots in Indianapolis?

Book a consultation and a Roots agent will help you turn the next move into a real plan.