Skip to content

5545 W 46th Street

Indianapolis, IN 46254

PendingListed Jul 23, 2026 · 56 days on market

Key facts

Beds
4
Baths
2 full
Living area
2,636 sqft
Lot
5.35 acres
Year built
1872
Type
Residential · Single Family Residence
Stories
Two
MLS #
22107875
County
Marion
Subdivision
Subdivision Not Available See Legal
Total building area
3,276 sqft

About this home

Owners had added another 3.3-acre tax parcel to this home since it was last on the market! That additional acreage has a hard-to-find barn in good condition. True needle-in-a-haystack opportunity-5.35 acres inside the I-465 loop with charming 150-year-old farmhouse, historic character, and endless possibilities. Step onto the welcoming wraparound porch and a home filled with craftsmanship that's nearly impossible to find today. Original woodwork, soaring ceilings, transom windows, stained glass, and spacious rooms create a warm, inviting atmosphere rich with history. The large attic offers excellent storage and exciting potential for future finished living space. Outside, you'll discover a peaceful retreat that feels worlds away from the city. Mature walnut, hackberry, and maple trees provide beauty and shade, while the growing fields and native prairie attract birds, butterflies, dragonflies, fireflies, and other wildlife. Enjoy sunrise coffee on the porch, host family and friends in the barn, or simply relax and take in the surroundings. The back porch and adjacent laundry room make the perfect transition after a day spent outdoors. Continue legacy of the current owners as a working urban vegetable and flower farm, or bring your own vision to life. With no HOA, the possibilities are endless-create a wood-fired pizza farm where guests gather picnic-style to enjoy pizzas topped with produce grown just steps away, pair it with a U-pick flower farm, or fence a portion of the property for animals to create an unforgettable destination for families. Existing chicken house stays! Whether dreaming of a hobby farm, agritourism business, event venue, or simply a private country retreat with room to roam, opportunities like this are exceptionally rare-especially in such a convenient location. Sale includes a total of 5.35 acres across three tax parcels: 490513117008000600, 4905131100100600, and 490513117009000600. Please include all three parcels with any offer.

Description provided by the listing brokerage.

Interior

Appliances
DryerMicrowaveGas OvenRefrigeratorWasherWater HeaterWater Softener Owned
Interior features
Attic StairwayBuilt-in FeaturesHi-Speed Internet AvailblWired for SoundWood Work Stained
Flooring
Hardwood
Rooms
14

Exterior

Patio and porch
CoveredWrap Around
Construction
Wood Siding
Foundation
BlockStone
Style
Farmhouse

Systems

Heating
Forced Air
Cooling
Central Air
Water
PublicPrivate

Lot and HOA

Lot features
Not In SubdivisionMature Trees

Schools

School district
MSD Pike Township

Taxes

Estimated annual tax
$6,906 / yearTwice the semi-annual installment the listing reports.
Tax year
2025

Estimate your monthly payment

$4,079per month, estimated
Principal and interest $3,276Property tax $576Insurance $227
20% · $129,980
6.47%
Loan type
Loan term

Estimates only. This calculator does not give a quote. Defaults reflect Marion County / Indianapolis averages: property tax from this home's actual county bill, homeowners insurance at 0.42% annually. Conventional: PMI runs 0.55% of the loan annually when your down payment is below 20%, and drops automatically at 22% equity. Your real number depends on credit, taxes assessed for the parcel, escrow, condo insurance, and HOA. Rates as of May 2026 and subject to change.

Talk to a lender we trust
Talk to Roots

Want us to run the numbers with you?

Book a consultation and a Roots agent will help you pressure-test the payment, repairs, resale, and rent.

Listed at$649,900
Talk to Roots

Ready to plant roots in Indianapolis?

Book a consultation and a Roots agent will help you turn the next move into a real plan.