Roots Deal Sheet

I Would Love For You to Reply...

Million Dollar Portfolio For Sale + I Want Your Feedback On This Story

January 30, 2026Property Update
I Would Love For You to Reply...

Happy Friday Roots Community!

Please take 3 minutes to read the story below, and let me know what you think of this story:

Awhile back, my team had a client reach out from out of state with the goal of investing in Indianapolis.

On our intro call, they shared five non-negotiables:

  1. It has to cash flow

  2. I need to be able to add value

  3. I want passive income

  4. B-class neighborhood or better

  5. Must be a multifamily

My response?

What month are you planning to relocate to Indianapolis?”

There’s really only one strategy that checks all five of those boxes at once—and that’s house hacking. Living in one unit, renovating the other, rotating tenants, adding value, and eventually moving out.

I’ve seen this work. This year alone, a client refinanced and pulled out roughly the equivalent of their annual salary.

But that’s not what this client meant.

They had been told—by books, media, and even another agent in my market—that all five goals could be achieved remotely, without sacrifice.

That’s just not reality.

Not because of interest rates.
Not because of Indianapolis.

It’s because adding value is harder from a distance, and most real wealth in real estate is created through value-add.

So instead of forcing a “perfect” deal, we adjusted the strategy.

For their first purchase, we focused on stable, tenant-occupied assets with upside. Properties in the ~$140k–$165k range, near the 1% rule, with rent in place from day one—before the first mortgage payment was even due.

That led us to a better opportunity.

We closed on a 12-unit portfolio:

  • 10 units fully leased and producing

  • 2 single-family homes with light value-add potential

Did it check every box on day one? No.
Did it work? Absolutely.

Fast forward two years.

I recently checked in and asked how things were going. Their response:

“It’s going perfectly. I wouldn’t trade these properties for anything.”

They’re still living in California.
They never house-hacked.
And they own a clean, well-running portfolio—because they were willing to adjust their expectations instead of chasing promises.

So if you needed to hear this today, here it is:

The play right now isn’t perfection.
It’s buying achievable, headache-light assets with room to grow. Do you agree??

We’re currently working on another portfolio that fits that exact mold—one value-add property, multiple tenant-occupied rentals near the 1% rule, and strong depreciation potential for W-2 buyers.

If you want to walk through it, just reply to this email.

— Max

Your Next Insurance Stop…

Before I jump into our portfolio deal of the day, I want to give a major shoutout to our exclusive insurance partner, Jackson Blevins from Core Insurance Solutions. Jackson takes care of our clients weekly with an unbelievable level of detail and care.

Hit Jackson up for any of your insurance needs: Personal, Commercial, or Property!

Your Next Insurance Stop…, from Roots Deal Sheet: I Would Love For You to Reply...

Your Next Insurance Stop…, from Roots Deal Sheet: I Would Love For You to Reply...

$1.25 Million for the Portfolio

(Everything Below Included)

818 N Oakland Ave
3b / 1b | No-Brainer Flip Opportunity

Mechanicals and roof all in good shape. Just needs a cosmetic rehab. Looking at a $200k ARV on a really solid area of Oakland.

Long Term Rentals:

PROPERTY

BED / BATH

Monthly RENT

Lease Expiration

3034 Guilford Ave

4/2

$1,845

8/31/26

3028 Guilford Ave

2 / 1.5

$1,450

6/30/26

1234 N Ewing St

4/1

$1,425

7/31/26

1816 Koehne St

2/1

$1,240

7/29/26

1448 St Peters St

2/1

$1,130

8/27/26

1452 Hoyt Ave
2b / 1b | AirBnb BEAUTY

Turnkey Indy Airbnb generating $120/day, stylish renovation, prime location near downtown/fountain square, strong cash flow opportunity for investors seeking high returns.

How Can You Finance This Deal??

Book a call with our partner Seth Wilcock to find out 😉 Seth just came on our podcast to drop some serious investor/financing game, and you WILL learn something if you give it a watch. Truly, he’s an incredibly Mortgage Loan Officer and person, and you should consider him on your next deal:

I truly value and appreciates everyone who reads this far. Hope you liked today’s story and portfolio offer. Let me know what you thought!

You have to dig into the mud to find the gold, which starts by simply taking ACTION. To get started here’s our Indy Investor Resources (guides, podcasts, courses, events coming soon, you name it).

Need an Agent? Talk about your Strategy / Goals? —> Roots Realty Co. Website

Follow along with us —>  Connect with us on Instagram 

Follow along with us —> Connect with us on LinkedIn

Roots Realty Co. is the investment-minded, education-first brokerage team in Indianapolis. We offer buying, selling, investing services, as well as one-of-a-kind educational content and networking opportunities. Get plugged in, just go to our website and book a chat!

PS - I’d love your feedback. How can we better set up this deal sheet? What would you like to see more of? - Max & Trace (Roots Deal SheetTeam)

All issues

More issues

See all issues
Newsletter

Get the next one before it is an archive.

Market notes, deal math, and Indy events, twice a month. One signup, both sends.

Read by Indianapolis investors and homebuyers · Unsubscribe anytime
  • Property + Investment1st of every month
  • Roots Update15th of every month