Skip to content
Investing

Indiana Cut Property Taxes, So Why Did My Rental Bill Rise?

Indiana's SEA 1 cut taxes for homeowners, but Marion County rentals sit at the 2% cap. Here is why the rental deduction does little yet, and how I underwrite taxes.

Max MooreNovember 17, 20267 min read

The headlines said Indiana cut property taxes. Then a lot of Indianapolis landlords opened a spring bill that was higher than the one before it. Both things are true, and the reason sits in one number: the 2% cap.

Bar chart of Indiana's rental property tax deduction by pay year: 6% in 2026, 12% in 2027, 19% in 2028, 25% in 2029, 30% in 2030 and 33.4% in 2031, with a line at about 26.7%, the estimated point where an Indianapolis Center rental leaves the 2% cap

Here is how Senate Enrolled Act 1 (2025) works for a Marion County rental, why it has done little for most of them so far, and what I run on every deal now. This is general information and is not tax or legal advice. Check your own parcel with the county assessor or a property tax attorney.

The tax cut went to homeowners

SEA 1 (as amended by HEA 1427) is a homeowner bill first. A home you live in keeps a standard deduction that steps down from $48,000 and a supplemental deduction that grows from 40% to 66.7% of the remaining value, per the Department of Local Government Finance (DLGF) memo of May 27, 2026. Starting in 2026 a homestead also gets a credit of the lesser of 10% of its tax bill or $300 (DLGF legislative update FAQ, June 2025). Purdue's Larry DeBoer says it plainly in his November 2025 report: "There is no supplemental credit for rental housing."

Rentals did get something. A new deduction for property at the 2% cap lowers assessed value by a percentage that grows every year. Here is the schedule from the DLGF memo:

Bills paid inRental deduction (share of assessed value)
20266%
202712%
202819%
202925%
203030%
2031 and after33.4%

Owners do not apply for it. The DLGF told county auditors to find eligible properties and apply it. The 2026 session bills (HEA 1210, HEA 1406, SEA 80 and SEA 163) left this schedule as it was, according to the same memo.

Why the deduction does little for a capped rental

Indiana limits a rental's property tax to 2% of its gross assessed value. A home you live in is limited to 1%, and commercial property to 3% (DLGF circuit breaker fact sheet). Residential for this purpose includes a building with two or more dwelling units. The key word is gross. The cap looks at the value before any deduction.

Now compare that to Marion County's tax rates. DLGF's 2026 certified file shows a gross rate of $2.7291 per $100 of assessed value in Indianapolis Center, down from $2.7858 the year before. Every one of Marion County's 61 tax districts in that file sits above $2.00, with the lowest at $2.3603. At those rates a rental's calculated tax is already higher than 2% of its gross value, so the county auditor trims it back to the cap. The bill is 2% of gross assessed value.

A deduction lowers net assessed value. It does nothing to a bill that is pinned to gross value. DeBoer wrote that when rates are high enough, rentals "will remain at their caps and SEA-1 will have no effect on their tax bills." He added that where rates are lower, the 33.4% deduction does matter.

Here is my own arithmetic for Indianapolis Center, with the rate and the assessed value held flat. This is our estimate.

  • A rental leaves the cap once rate x (1 - deduction) drops below $2.00. At $2.7291 that takes a deduction above about 26.7% (1 - 2.00 / 2.7291).
  • The 6%, 12%, 19% and 25% steps leave a capped Indianapolis Center rental at 2% of gross value. The 30% step in 2030 is the first one that can lower the bill.
  • On a $250,000 gross assessed value the capped bill is $5,000. At a 30% deduction the same property works out to about $4,776. At 33.4% it is about $4,544.
  • In the district with the lowest rate ($2.3603) the break-even is lower, about 15%, so the 19% step could help there.

Two things move that math. The certified rate includes referendum levies that sit outside the cap, so the true break-even for a given parcel differs a bit. And rates will change: DeBoer's report projects the statewide average rate climbing from $2.38 per $100 in 2025 to above $3 by 2031. If an Indianapolis rate climbed past about $3.00, even the full 33.4% deduction would leave a rental at its cap (2.00 / 0.666). Marion County's rates went down for bills paid in 2026 (Indianapolis Center fell about 2%, from 2.7858 to 2.7291), so the forecast has not shown up here yet.

What did go up: assessments

Because a capped bill moves with gross assessed value, assessments decide the bill. For apartment assessments, the DLGF removed a sizeable adjustment that assessors had applied, starting with the January 1, 2025 assessment date, which fed the bills paid in 2026. In Marion County the assessor added nearly $2 billion of assessed value across about 1,000 apartment complexes with 20 or more units, and the DLGF's second round of base rate increases in 2026 is expected to raise taxes for many apartment owners in 2027, according to Faegre Drinker.

For one-to-four unit rentals I could not find an official Marion County average change, so I will not print a number. The examples I trust come from our own team. Tyler's Butler-Tarkington short-term rental went from about $1,800 a year at purchase to a $6,275 bill in April 2026, and $951 of it showed up as special assessments. He walks through it in his Roots post on Marion County rental taxes and repeats the story in his guide to investment neighborhoods. That post covers the 2% cap table and the bill check, so I will leave it there. For caps by property type and how taxes fit into cash flow, see our guide to Indianapolis property taxes for real estate investors.

Voter-approved referendum levies are one more line to look for. The DLGF memo lists referendum levies as exempt at the property tax caps step, so they can push a bill above 2% of gross value. The Roots podcast episode with a mortgage lender covers Marion County bills up 2 to 3 times on some rentals and the squeeze that puts on cash flow.

The homestead trap for a house that becomes a rental

If you move out of a home and rent it, the homestead deductions and the 1% cap end. HEA 1210 requires you to tell the auditor within 60 days. Since July 1, 2026, back taxes plus a 10% civil penalty are mandatory for a homestead that was not reported (DLGF memo, May 27, 2026). Plan the new bill before you sign the first lease.

How I underwrite taxes now

I model taxes at Indiana's 2% non-homestead rate on every Roots Deal Sheet card. The tax line on a listing is whatever the current owner pays, and if the owner lives there it can be roughly half of what an investor will pay. Those homestead deductions end when someone who does not live there buys it, and the bill resets the year after the sale.

A Fountain Square duplex shows how big that gap gets. It listed at $499,000 with a $1,708 tax bill, which is 0.34% of the price. At 2% of the price the tax line is $9,980 a year, and I figured the building loses $1,142 a month. We benched it. A rule of thumb I use: a listing tax figure under about 0.8% of the asking price is an owner-occupant bill that roughly doubles after closing. Modeling at 2% of price is my shortcut. Your actual bill follows assessed value, which can differ from the price, so pull the assessment too.

Washington Manor: when the tax line sets the value

Tyler and I closed on Washington Manor on August 4, 2026. It is a nine-unit, 1920 building in Meridian-Kessler and our first commercial deal, bought with outside capital partners. It went under contract at $925,000 and closed at $875,000, and we negotiated a $50,000 credit for the knob-and-tube wiring. On the podcast we shared that net operating income (NOI) from the seller's records was about $42,000 and that we project about $86,000 once the units are renovated and re-rented. We put that at roughly $1.3 million at a 6.5 cap. Those are projections, and the results may differ. You can hear the full breakdown on our Washington Manor podcast episode.

Here is why that belongs in a tax post. A small apartment building is valued on its income, which means every operating expense, taxes included, comes out of NOI. At a 6.5 cap, each extra $1,000 a year of tax takes roughly $15,400 off the value (1,000 / 0.065). That is our arithmetic and it applies to any income property. I will not print a Washington Manor tax figure here. The tax line is part of the NOI that sets the value we are underwriting.

What to do now

  1. Check the bill against 2% of gross assessed value. Find the gross assessed value on your bill and multiply by 0.02. If your tax is near that number, you are capped and a bigger deduction will not change it yet. If it runs well above that, look for referendum or special assessment lines.
  2. Appeal if the value is wrong. The appeal starts with Form 130, one per parcel, filed with the county assessor. DLGF's rule is June 15 of the assessment year when the notice was mailed before May 1, and June 15 of the year taxes are due when it was mailed on or after May 1. Read the date on your own notice and calendar it early.
  3. Check your escrow. A higher bill usually means an escrow shortage and a higher monthly payment after the next review.
  4. Re-run cash flow on every door. Use the current bill plus an assessment bump for 2027, since more base rate increases are coming for apartments.
  5. Underwrite a purchase at 2%. Use the listing tax figure only after you confirm the owner does not hold a homestead deduction.

Talk through your numbers with us

Send us the address and the bill and we will run it with you over coffee. Every Roots agent invests too, and we would rather you find the surprise before closing than after.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Quick answers from this guide.

Why did my Indianapolis rental property tax go up if Indiana cut property taxes?

SEA 1's biggest breaks went to homesteads. A Marion County rental is held at 2% of its gross assessed value, so its bill moves with the assessment. For apartment assessments, DLGF removed a sizeable adjustment starting with the January 1, 2025 assessment date, and Marion's assessor added nearly $2 billion to about 1,000 apartment complexes with 20 or more units, per Faegre Drinker.

What is Indiana SEA 1 and how does it affect rental property taxes?

Senate Enrolled Act 1 (2025), as amended by HEA 1427, changes Indiana property tax. For rentals it adds a deduction that starts at 6% of assessed value for bills paid in 2026 and reaches 33.4% for bills paid in 2031. Rentals get no homestead credit.

Is there an Indiana rental property tax deduction under SEA 1?

Yes. The DLGF schedule for 2% cap property is 6% (bills paid 2026), 12% (2027), 19% (2028), 25% (2029), 30% (2030) and 33.4% (2031 and after). Owners do not apply, because auditors apply it automatically. A rental already held at its 2% cap sees little or no change until the deduction gets large enough.

Why doesn't the SEA 1 deduction lower my Marion County rental bill?

The 2% cap is figured on gross assessed value and the deduction lowers net assessed value. Marion County's gross rates run above $2.00 per $100, so many rentals are already held at the cap and the bill stays at 2% of gross value. Purdue's Larry DeBoer says capped rentals will see no effect from SEA 1 when rates are high enough.

When will the SEA 1 rental deduction start to matter in Indianapolis?

By our estimate, with the 2026 Indianapolis Center rate of $2.7291 per $100 and assessed value held flat, the deduction has to exceed about 26.7% before a rental leaves the cap. That points to the 30% step for bills paid in 2030. Rates and assessments will change, so treat it as a rough guide.

How do I check whether my Indy rental is at the 2% cap?

Multiply the gross assessed value on your bill by 0.02. If your annual tax is near that number, you are at the cap. If it runs well above it, look for voter-approved referendum levies and special assessment lines, which can sit outside the cap.

How do I appeal my Marion County rental property assessment?

File a Form 130 with the county assessor, one per parcel. DLGF's rule is June 15 of the assessment year when the notice was mailed before May 1, and June 15 of the year taxes are due when it was mailed on or after May 1. Read the date on your own notice.

What property tax rate should I use to underwrite an Indiana rental?

I model taxes at Indiana's 2% non-homestead rate and check the parcel's assessed value. A listing's tax figure comes from the current owner, and an owner-occupant's bill can be about half of what an investor will pay. It resets after a sale.
All articles
Talk to Roots

Ready to plant roots in Indianapolis?

Book a consultation and a Roots agent will help you turn the next move into a real plan.